
Collecting Southern Stoneware
Southern alkaline-glazed stoneware has collectors in every state where it was made, and a few names draw buyers everywhere. Edgefield, South Carolina, and the enslaved potter Dave sit at the center of the field.
Who collects Southern stoneware, and what was hot in 2004
Many kinds of Southern antique stoneware are prized by knowledgeable collectors, and they come at it from different directions. Some want only their own state’s pottery. Others collect only jugs, bowls, pitchers or face jugs. Still others follow particular potters, such as Cheever or Arie Meaders.
In 2004 the hottest name was Burlon Craig, especially his early face jugs. Craig was a potter from the Catawba Valley of North Carolina, where alkaline-glazed pottery has a tradition almost as old as Edgefield’s. He was the last surviving link to the area’s traditional potters, and after his death a few years earlier, some of his early work could command more than $1,000.
Other names turn up in good collections too. A five-gallon Catawba Valley jug, unsigned but attributed to Samuel Propst (1882 to 1935), is the kind of piece buyers look for, and a signed Propst example sold for several thousand dollars. A five-gallon churn by Cheever Meaders and high-fired, high-quality alkaline-glazed pottery from Sand Mountain, Alabama, from around 1880 are also sought after.

Rules of thumb for valuing Southern stoneware
Hot names come and go. Dealers who also collect tend to care more about what holds and grows in value over time, and a few rules of thumb apply. The first is simple: the older, the better. It also helps if the potter is not still producing pieces and flooding the market.
Rarity counts, because collectors want what they do not have, and condition is part of rarity. A form can be fairly common yet rarely survive in mint condition. Large two-handled jugs of five gallons or more are a good example. They were almost always used hard and worn or damaged in the process, so an early large jug without damage is rare and worth more, even though two-handled jugs themselves are not unusual.
Attribution to a particular area or maker adds value. Most potters sign their work today, but that was not always so, and an unsigned old piece that can be tied to a known shop is worth more than one that cannot.
Edgefield pottery and the alkaline glaze tradition
Region matters too, without any one region being better than another. A Georgia dealer may struggle to find Catawba Valley collectors close to home, and Crawford County, Georgia, collectors are scarce in North Carolina. Serious Edgefield collectors, though, can be found almost everywhere, in both states and beyond.
The reason is history. Edgefield, South Carolina, is where the Southern alkaline-glazed pottery tradition began, so it has the broadest base of collectors. Its influence spread across the region; pottery from Crawford County, Georgia, for instance, plainly shows it. A B.F. Landrum jug made in Edgefield around 1860 is a classic of the type, and B.F. Landrum’s uncle is credited with introducing alkaline glazing to the South. Southern folk traditions of other kinds, such as the Highwaymen painters of Florida or the sand bottles of Andrew Clemens, draw a similar crowd of regional collectors.

Dave the slave pottery and the potter’s poems
Nearly everyone who collects Southern stoneware knows who Dave was. Dave was an enslaved potter, famous for turning wares that sometimes carry short poems written on the vessel. That meant he could read and write in a time and place where this was not accepted for an enslaved man, and it is surely what first made him notable. He was also known for his ability to turn very large pieces. He worked for various potteries and owners in Edgefield for many years.
Apart from his pottery, surprisingly little is known about him, and a good deal of folklore has grown up around him. His own lines are the clearest record. On August 16, 1857, he wrote: “I wonder where is all my relations / Friendship to all, and every nation.” On July 4, 1859: “The forth of July is surely come / To blow the fife and beat the drum.” On April 12, 1858: “A very large jar which has four handles / pack it full of fresh meat, then light candles.” And on August 7, 1860: “I saw a leopard & a lion’s face / then I felt the need of grace.”
Other poems are practical. On April 8, 1858, he wrote, “This noble jar will hold 20 / Fill it with silver then you’ll have plenty,” and on November 9, 1860, “A noble jar for pork or beef / Then carry it a round to the indian chief.”

Identifying Dave pottery: attributions and marks
For collectors, Dave pieces fall into four basic categories. The first and most common is work attributed to Dave. Collectors and dealers who handle a lot of his pottery can recognize it much like handwriting. Styles may change a great deal over the years, but a small detail, such as the way a handle is attached, may stay exactly the same. This is true of almost any potter. It takes a very sharp eye, but it can be done. A tall storage jar attributed to Dave was priced at $2,750 in 2004.
The second category is pieces with marks strongly associated with Dave. Working back from signed pieces and from digs at sites where he made a great deal of pottery, scholars and collectors have identified marks that are more likely his: a horseshoe symbol, slashes used in a certain way, punctuates (dots marking capacity) and X’s. X’s and slashes are fairly common on Edgefield pieces, though.
Dave was not the only enslaved potter in Edgefield, and others used the same kinds of marks because they were required to. Deciding whose marks appear on a piece is uncertain at best, and common marks may come from other potters, used to show capacity or production. A five-gallon jar with five slashes is different from one with two. Even so, a piece can only be attributed to Dave if it also looks like what is thought to have come from his hand. Some mark configurations identify a pottery rather than a potter, a reminder that reading marks on any antique, as the antique detective guides explain, takes context.

LM jars and pieces signed Dave
The third category is pieces marked LM in script, written by hand rather than stamped. LM stands for Lewis Miles, who is believed to have owned the pottery where Dave worked late in his life. Whether Miles owned Dave himself is not known with certainty. There is almost no doubt that Dave turned the LM pieces, because of the handwriting, which is about the only hard evidence about Dave that exists. That assumes the script matches known samples and the piece fits his body of work.
LM pieces nearly always carry other marks too, such as the horseshoe, which is part of why pieces with the same marks but no LM strongly suggest Dave. Some LM pieces are also dated, and these are highly desirable. One Dave jar marked LM, written vertically near the rim, with a horseshoe, a slash, a date and punctuates, sold for $14,000.
The final category is pottery actually signed “Dave” in script on the side of the jar or jug. Apart from the handful of pieces with poems, these bring the highest prices, and far fewer exist. They usually also carry a date, LM and other marks, and they look like the rest of his known work. The best advice for any stoneware buyer is simple: it is hard to overpay for a piece you love so much you would never sell it at any reasonable offer.
Questions and answers
Who was Dave the slave potter?
Dave was an enslaved potter who worked for various potteries and owners in Edgefield, South Carolina, for many years. He is famous for writing short poems on some of his vessels, showing he could read and write when that was not accepted, and for turning very large pieces. Little else about him is known.
How can you identify Dave pottery?
Dave pieces fall into four groups: pieces attributed to him by style, pieces with marks linked to him such as the horseshoe, slashes, punctuates and X’s, pieces marked LM in script for Lewis Miles, and pieces signed Dave. Signed pieces and those with poems are the most valuable.
What does LM mean on Edgefield stoneware?
LM, written in script rather than stamped, stands for Lewis Miles, who is believed to have owned the pottery where Dave worked late in his life. Because the handwriting is Dave’s, LM pieces are almost certainly his work. One LM jar with a horseshoe, slash, date and punctuates sold for $14,000.
What makes Southern stoneware valuable?
Age, rarity and condition come first, along with the ability to tie a piece to a maker or area. Large early two-handled jugs of five gallons or more are valuable without damage because most were worn out by use. Edgefield pieces have the widest base of collectors.
Who was Burlon Craig?
Burlon Craig was a potter from the Catawba Valley of North Carolina and the last surviving link to that area’s traditional alkaline-glaze potters. In 2004 his early face jugs were among the hottest Southern stoneware, and some of his early work could bring more than $1,000.
